Dealer Login

Common Misconceptions About Profit Participation Programs for Auto Dealerships

By Scott Christopher | Jul 19, 2024

Last updated on Jul 23, 2024

Running a successful dealership is about a lot more than simply selling cars. Optimizing multiple revenue streams is not only a popular move these days but also a smart one. It’s a solid way to maximize profitability and offset potential fluctuations in the automotive market, as well.

Profit participation programs and auto reinsurance options can make excellent sources of additional income for your dealership. But properly understanding them and how to leverage them to your dealership’s advantage can be a challenge on several levels.

Take the Profit Participation Program Self-Assessment

How Can Auto Dealers Better Understand Profit Participation Programs?

Misconceptions about profit participation programs and what they involve are common, so it’s crucial to have a trusted partner to help separate fact from fiction before making important decisions.

In this handy guide, we’ll cover everything modern dealership owners should know about understanding profit participation programs to make smart, profitable choices every time.

What Are Profit Participation Programs in Car Dealerships?

Profit participation programs offer dealerships valuable opportunities to share in the underwriting and investment income generated from the sales of F&I products, as well as any associated underwriting risks. Some programs may pay out upfront upon completion of a sale, while profit participation programs might reward dealerships with long-term wealth-building opportunities over time, tax breaks, or a combination of rewards.

Many profit participation programs leverage reinsurance in which reinsured premiums are ceded to a separate reinsurance company. Although the dealer is taking on more risk, they can also take part in tax benefits and earnings from underwriting and investment income.

Myths and Misconceptions About Profit Participation Programs for Auto Dealerships

The advantages, considerations and structure involved can vary from one type of program to the next. As a result, profit sharing programs for auto dealerships are widely misunderstood. Let’s dive into some of the most common myths to be aware of.

Common Misconceptions Profit Participation-01

Myth #1: Profit participation programs are too complicated to implement

When you get into the various benefits and services associated with different F&I options and start discussing the nuances of how each program works, it can seem complicated. But well-designed programs are much more straightforward than they may seem at first glance.

The key is to choose both your program and the provider behind it carefully. The right F&I provider should:

  • Offer a variety of options suited to different goals and objectives
  • Work with you to create understanding of profit participation programs
  • Help you make the right choices for your business
  • Make the process of getting set up as simple as possible

Myth #2: Only large dealerships really benefit from profit participation programs

Just as dealerships don’t need to be huge to develop loyal customer bases and be financially successful, they also don’t need to be a specific size to benefit from profit sharing programs, either. Today’s programs are flexible and completely scalable.

In other words, the offering provider will tailor your program to fit your dealership, business goals and unique needs. This means any dealership can benefit from the right program and airtight implementation.

Myth #3: Profit participation programs aren’t really that profitable

It’s only natural to be skeptical of any program that claims you can make good money sharing in another company’s profits. Many people worry that it sounds too good to be true and that there must be a catch somewhere. Others assume that the programs must be more trouble than they’re worth, so they can’t be that profitable.

In reality, profit participation programs are what you make of them, and the potential to earn solid revenue is there. Proper setup, comprehensive orientation, and a full understanding of the program you choose are the keys to success here.

The Realities of Profit Participation Programs for Automotive Dealers

  • They can significantly add to your profits, accelerating business growth in the process.
  • They support optimal profit retention and financial security.
  • Providers tailor programs to fit the dealership and its unique business vision, not the other way around.

With the right partner, today's programs can be easy to implement and incorporate into the way you run your dealership, regardless of its type or size. Amazing program providers have a vested interest in your ultimate success, so they provide all the support you need to get ahead.

These are programs that revolve around a shared culture of mutual long-term success. Establishing a strong, transparent relationship with the right provider and carefully monitoring your results over time are the keys to lasting success.

Industry Data in Support of Profit Sharing Programs

The automotive industry is constantly changing. New technology, shifting consumer expectations, and evolving standards mean dealerships interested in staying competitive and profitable need to evolve, as well.

Profit sharing programs are just one highly effective way to do this, because participating in the right programs helps bolster profits and support a more robust bottom line. And of course, healthy profit margins help keep dealerships resilient and better equipped to navigate industry changes and shifts.

At JM&A Group, our comprehensive F&I service offerings, transparency, and support lead to genuine, sustained growth for our partners.


For example, according to recent automotive trends data, the industry has seen a marked uptick in service contracts. Taking part in a profit participation program that incorporates key automotive services into the mix could allow a dealership to benefit from shifts like these. Profits swing upwards along with associated trends, and you directly benefit.

Take the Profit Participation Program Self-Assessment

How to Successfully Implement a Dealership Reinsurance Profit Participation Program

Even exciting, beneficial changes call for some adjustment. Here’s a closer look at some helpful tips for choosing and implementing the right profit participation program for your dealership.

Common Misconceptions Profit Participation-02

Analyze what your customers want

Ultimately, your customers are at the center of all you do as a dealership owner, so it’s crucial to consider their needs and expectations when exploring potential changes. Choose F&I programs that include your most popular products to ensure sales of these contracts contribute to the success of your profit participation plan.

Offer customers a robust service menu that includes must-haves like premium service packages, roadside assistance, etc. Look for options that not only allow you to match what other dealerships can offer but raise the bar a notch or two, as well, to encourage buyer adoption.

Evaluate alignment with your needs

The right profit participation program for your needs is one that fully aligns with your ultimate vision for your business, as well as its current structure. Does the option you’re considering enable you to achieve your long- and short-term goals? How might participating in it help you better realize your potential?

When you go over the specifics of a particular program, make sure you can picture leveraging its structure and benefits to help your business grow.

Plan a thorough training program

Understanding profit participation programs may start with you, but it continues with the rest of your team. Making the transition from one way of doing things to another takes time, patience and strategy.

Help your staff develop the understanding they’ll need to succeed with comprehensive training. Make sure each member of your team comes out of it with the ability to bring their best to your program of choice.

Step into the Future with Profit Participation Programs for Auto Dealerships

Any industry experiences peaks and valleys, and the automotive business is no different. But exploring multiple ways to help your dealership succeed and stay profitable can help you stay ahead of the game and reach your goals.

Embracing a profit participation program that’s right for your business, customer base, and value system is a terrific way to maximize your dealership’s potential. However, understanding your options and how to implement the right ones is imperative.

Free Tool: Find the ideal profit participation program - take the assessment