When it comes to operating an auto dealership, it’s vital to be knowledgeable and comfortable when choosing a profit participation model. There are plenty of factors that go into profit participation, but taxes are a crucial aspect because they can deeply impact the outcomes dealers are looking for. We're here to help you understand the implications of profit-sharing models for car dealerships.
To help you have a better bottom line coupled with peace of mind, we’re diving into some of the details of this complex topic so you can select the right program for your needs.
What Should Auto Dealerships Know About Tax Efficiency?
When choosing a profit participation program, it’s essential to consider how your profits are taxed. The right structure should balance this, along with your financial goals and desire to participate in underwriting.
Evaluate Current Profit Participation Programs
The first step toward understanding the dealership profit sharing tax impact and related factors is to review and evaluate your current program. Does it meet your expectations? If you aren't getting what you anticipated, or if the program you have is no longer the right fit for your goals and risk tolerance, making a change may be the right thing to do.
As you review your options, you'll want to look at how different models affect your finances, including income taxes and deferred liabilities to find a program that best addresses all the aspects that make up your tax burden. Don't just look at whether your income taxes will be lower, or whether one program is better at addressing liabilities over time. Looking at the complete picture will give you the best insights and results.
How Profit Participation Programs Affect Dealership Taxes
The biggest differences in tax implications are between participating (par) and non-participating (non-par) programs. Non-participating programs like 1+ Commission and Guaranteed Retro are taxed as regular income, whereas participating programs have more complex tax models.
1+ Commission & Guaranteed Retro (GR)
The 1+ commission structure is straightforward, which makes it predictable and easier to manage. Since you know what to expect from each F&I sale, you can more easily keep up with the dealership profit sharing tax impact this creates. Guaranteed Retro is more flexible because your dealership will earn more per contract as you sell larger volumes. This can have a bigger effect on your cash flow, but it also means you'll need to be ready for the potential of higher taxes for higher performance.
Retrospective Commission
In a retrospective commission structure, you participate in the underwriting performance of contract sales without the risk of reinsurance. Returns are taxed as ordinary income, as with non-par structures, but have the benefit of earning on the invested reserves. You have the potential to receive income in an annual commission payment.
Producer-Affiliated Reinsurance Company (PARC)
Known by several names, including PARC, PORC, DORC and CFC, this option is utilized by dealers who do not need upfront cash and are looking to maximize their participation and tax benefits. Distributions are taxed as qualified dividends, which is the same rate as long-term capital gains. Owners have the flexibility to request distributions when funds are available in the account or defer profits, thereby deferring income taxation for the period.
Non-Controlled Foreign Corporation (NCFC)
The NCFC is often utilized by large-volume dealers that wish to defer income. Dealers receive upfront F&I commission on product sales and tax-deferred underwriting and investment income. Distributions are treated as qualified dividends and taxed at the long-term capital gains rate. However, as a participating structure that involves multiple dealers, there is more risk involved, and dealers participate in both gains and losses. However, large returns are typically generated in this structure type.
Dealer Owned Warranty Corporation (DOWC)
Like an NCFC, a DOWC is typically used by large dealer groups and has the potential for high investment returns. In the case of a DOWC, it comes with the advantage of significant tax deferral for 5-7 years as well as shorter-term access to profits generated. Risk is limited, but this structure requires ongoing operational fees and is subject to both federal and state income taxes and regulatory oversight, but not premium taxes. Overall, DOWCs can be quite complex to manage, which is a consideration dealers should keep in mind when selecting their program.
Customizable/Hybrid Programs
If you think a mix of these might be perfect for your dealership, you're not alone. It's possible to create a hybrid model and tailor it for optimal tax efficiency and access to capital. In a custom model, you can combine aspects of participating and/or non-participating structures, but this is typically reserved for large dealer groups due to its complexity.
Consult with Experts to Align Profit Participation with Dealership Goals
Understanding dealership profit participation programs is instrumental in choosing one that fits your current needs, risk level and goals to help you move toward the future. The best thing you can do before making a selection is consult with tax experts who are experienced in automotive profit participation models and who can help you navigate complex tax issues. Customized tax planning can help minimize liabilities and maximize profitability as you move through regular reviews, since tax laws and circumstances can change quickly.
The Bottom Line on Tax Efficiency in Auto Dealerships
Understanding the tax implications of F&I profit participation models takes time, and even after research and study it can still be confusing. Fortunately, there are options to help you get the answers you need and to help make the best choice for your dealership.
After all, a well-chosen profit participation model can have a significant impact on the financial health and tax efficiency of your dealership. Not only is that good news for where you are now, but it can mean a brighter and more comfortable future, as well. In short, the benefits you can receive are worth the time and resources to choose wisely or considering whether to switch.
You can focus on proactive steps to help your dealership by taking a free profit participation program assessment to start evaluating your current program, comparing models, aligning with your goals and consulting with experts. Want to know more about profit participation programs and tax strategies for auto dealerships? JM&A Group can help you find the program that meets your goals.
< 1 min read
Podcast